culture of honor outliers

Kentucky in the 1800s. 1. Chapter 5 looked at the way Joe Floms Jewish culture provided him with several opportunities that paved his way to extraordinary success. Guidelines on how to get the 1gig 1.Go to playstore and search for my airtel app 2.Download it and install it 3.You will be required to enter your airtel number and OTP will be sent to you 4.After some minutes, you will be sent a message of receiving airtel app bonus 5.Dial *140# to check your balance as you are ready to explore the Internet Do not panic as the messages may take up to 8-10 minutes. The culture of honor phrase was heavily discussed in Malcolm Gladwells Entertainment Weekly National Bestselling book entitled Outliers and even more specifically, in chapter six, Harlan, Kentucky. In the mist of the mountainous land of the Cumberland Plateau, which can also be known as the Appalachian Mountains, lies the small town of Harlan, Kentucky. Instant downloads of all 1681 LitChart PDFs By 03 Nov, 2020 Uncategorized 03 Nov, 2020 Uncategorized Chapter 6 discusses the impact of our traditions and attitudes that are inherited from our ancestors. culture of honor outliers. For instance, in class we referenced Malcolm Gladwells Outliers. Many of the conflicts that arise are issues dealing with competition, property, and respect. Feuds were not only the norm in this small During the novel, the author discusses how people who are successful are only successful due a great opportunity, lots of hard work, to it. The culture passes down from generation to generation, even if the newest generation is in a different situation that no longer requires the cultural behaviors. Good start! Cultural legacies are powerful forces. Gladwell wants to make the point, in his remaining chapters, that traditions and attitudes of our forbearers also have an impact on our success. He proposes that this propensity has been transferred to other ethnic groups by shared culture, whence it can be traced to different urban populations of the United States. I think people living in eastern China also have the culture of honor; Although sometimes they may complain or make jokes to people or things in their regions, but that's just allowed to do by themselves. Growing Crops - Why the thing is though this only occurs when you have an enviornment to teach you this, growing up i had to create my enviornment, because the people i had to teach me died. 19th-century education reformers did not benefit from the cultural legacy of diligence.). repeatedly ended in violence and death. Herdsman vs. While those families were killing each other, identical incidents were taking place in various towns along the Appalachians. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Culture of Honor: Why the South Is More Violent. their feud is attributed to a "culture of honor" in their society. In Outliers, a culture of honor is one in which resources are scarce, and it is important for a familys survival that they Gladwell uses cultures of honor as an example of the continuing power of cultural legacies. At that time, the earlist immigrants there were from Scotch-Irish. i have only minor teachings from them that affect me today, but the way they were and how they embraced it i will never know, except, for a few of my fathers religious deeds and teachings that he told me. Once other people insult our own culture, there is no deny that we will defend our civilization whatever the loss is, even our lives. By passing these ideas along to their children, they are taking part in social conditioning. Yes, I consent to your idea. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Give examples from your country. WebOutliers: Chapter 6 Summary & Analysis Next Chapter 7 Themes and Colors Key Summary Analysis 1. More time. We need to be able to develop our talent, and while our work ethic may be part of our personalities, it is also influenced by our cultural legacy. They knew that the actions of the families of Harlan in the nineteenth century were a product of patterns laid down in the English borderlands centuries before. Learn how the culture of honor began with farming practices in the past, and why it continues centuries later today. As a reason, I did not want to become embarrassed when we met in the future because of the brawl. WebCultural legacies are the customs of a family or a group of people, that is inherited through the generations. Outliers Chapter 6 In Chapter 6 of the Outliers, Malcom Gladwell talked about a 'culture of honor' and how people who come from ancestors who their life was herding were more aggressive and had to protect their reputation. Step #2: The researchers then asked the men to read a story about one man hitting on another mans fianc. Power Distance Index: Definition and Examples, The Importance of Play in Early Childhood, What People Search on Google: Confessions, Code Switching Meaning + How Junior Code Switches, U.S. Federal Gun Laws: A Brief Overview in Simple Terms, The Real Cost of a PS5: How Scalpers Own the Market, Why the U.S. Should Reform the Supreme Court. Culture of Honor: Why the South Is More Violent - Shortform 70(5), Brown, Ryan P., Osterman, Lindsey L., & Barnes, Collin D. "School Violence and the Culture of Honor," 20(11), Osterman, L. L. & Brown, R. P., "Culture of Honor and Violence Against the Self," 37(12), particularly the chapter titled "Borderlands to the Backcountry: The Flight from Middle Britain and Northern Ireland, 1717-1775", Albion's Seed: Four British Folkways in America, http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-human-beast/200904/is-southern-violence-due-culture-honor, http://www.simine.com/240/readings/Cohen_et_al_(2).pdf, http://www.uta.fi/arkisto/aktk/projects/sta/Brown_Osterman_Barnes_2009_School-Violence-and-the-Culture-of-Honour.pdf, https://www.academia.edu/1069747/Culture_of_Honor_and_Violence_Against_the_Self, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Culture_of_honor_(Southern_United_States)&oldid=1123789977, Wikipedia articles needing factual verification from March 2021, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 25 November 2022, at 18:19. They realized this through the pattern of fights and feuds between families in the Appalachia area. In China, because of numbers of wars happened there, the honor will be much obvious. Same here when u go north in my country. Bill Joy: How This Outlier Enjoyed the Luck of Timing, Why Humans Have a Natural Creative Impulse, Want to Increase Sales? Gladwell makes the concept seem like a very strange and unique idea, but let it be known that culture of honor is everywhere. A herdsman is the owner or keeper of a herd of domesticated animals. Cultural legacies are not really a unique way of creating outliers; it is just a specified way of influence. The culture of honor is a theory by anthropologists who believed these early settlers only killed friends and family, (Outliers, p.249) However, Gladwell only mentions Scotch-Irish descents, in which he believes their herding cultural heritage allowed them to respond to threats more than agriculture people. The theory is that developing a reputation for violent retribution against those who stole herd animals was one way to discourage theft. No matter what happens, Chinese always smile to others firstly, isn't it? He explains that this lifestyle is In the 1990s, psychologists at the University of Michigan conducted an experiment to examine the legacy of the culture of honor in the south. that no one would dare steal their livestock. They believed that over-study could lead to insanity, so they shortened the school day, eliminated Saturday classes, and developed the idea of a summer vacation. no no no, I am one of your northern boy, but I am polite, peaceful, and kind(lol), so in my point of view, the situation is the things that are more abstract; for example, the education is one of the most effective things. When lots of families fight with one another then it is a pattern. If you live on some Cultures of honor tend to take root in highlands and, Study found that there was a group of real successes and there was a group of real failures, and that the successes were far more likely to have come from wealthier families. BCv12wK$8FA'j-4%o*s4H&0}rRL"'%'KFKW8$PAVY?r[;0e8'*y|NK0pp@UD?=s;|'+*D9W. Deciding not to say what you feel creates what researchers call cognitive dissonance between what you truly believe (in your hear, Demographic trough(Outliers by Malcolm Gladwell). The series of experiments included filling out and completing a questionnaire and returning it to a file cabinet at the very end of an extremely long and narrow hallway. As well as being a bestselling author of four books, Gladwell is a speaker and still continues to work as writer for The New Yorker since starting in 1996. This affects our present-day culture, and thus our present-day success. The original text plus a side-by-side modern translation of. Opportunities like this make school work meaningful. Risking getting emotional or upsetting someone so that you can express yourself is scary, but the result is magical. A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality study guides that feature detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, quotes, and essay topics. People can and glad to fight with others because of their honor, and their honor can be meant by anything. Nice shot. A good set of successful people in the world today that I have chosen to talk, The coined phrase Culture of Honor harps on the theoretical idea that the Southern United States at all costs tries to avoid intentionally insulting or offending each other. In mountainous areas such as Harlan, Kentucky, the principal type of culture of honor would be the one that Gladwell addresses. They depend on themselvesshow more content It is first developed when youre young by mostly parents, teacher, and even friends. Studies show that crimes in the south tend to be personal and more violent than crimes in the north. The mother of the Howards was so in tuned with the environment and world of gunshots around her that she had her expectations for her sons death. They epitomized the notion of a family feud. Over time, reputation becomes increasingly important. Areas unsuitable for agriculture, like rocky, mountainous areas, foster a culture of honor. Sign up for a free trial here . For protecting our culture and our country, Zexu Lin who was a official in Qin Dynasty warring to drift these foreign people. Teachers and parents! In 1819, eight immigrant families, The Howards and the Turners brawl ended fatally. Many students participate in extracurricular activities until 7:00 pm. They shook their hands to assess the firmness of their grip. and find 2022 for other outliers: turners inoutliersare two of the eight founding families of harlan county in kentucky. Learn the foundations of cultural legacy here. 2-4. Share to others as well Enjoy. Along with the Howards and Turners were just the focal points of Gladwells story. not live in harmony; this was simply the way things were. 317 Words2 Pages. My students love how organized the handouts are and enjoy tracking the themes as a class.. But culturally legacies can also be a source of weakness. Course Hero is not sponsored or endorsed by any college or university. Indeed, many of the residents of Appalachia were descendents of immigrants from the Scottish lowlands, the northern counties of England, and Ulster in Northern Irelandsome of the most ferocious cultures of honor in the world. Teach your students to analyze literature like LitCharts does. Its actually ending the silence between you. [4], The Southern culture of honor also includes a notion that ladies should not be insulted by gentlemen. In the case of Joe Flom, cultural legacy was a source of strength. outliers Friday, April 15, 2016 Chapter Six: Harlan, Kentucky and the culture of honor I believe the ideology that where and how ones ancestors many generations You dont have to worry much about neighbors stealing your livelihood because nobody can steal a field of crops overnight. Like this article? However, if I were in that situation, I might not able to control my emotions. pattern. And the cause of this pattern is what sociologists call a culture of The herdsman must demonstrate his aggression and strength to protect himself and his animals. When lots of families fight with one another in identical little towns up the same mountain range, its a pattern. And the cause of this pattern is what sociologists call a culture of honor. The original inhabitants of these tows were descended from Scots-Irish herdsman, whose livelihood depended on their being feared and respected enough that no one would dare steal their livestock. Here's what you'll find in our full Outliers summary : Allen Cheng is the founder of Shortform. (including. Detailed explanations, analysis, and citation info for every important quote on LitCharts. The historian David Hackett Fischer, a professor of history at Brandeis University, makes a case for an enduring genetic basis for a "willingness to resort to violence" (citing especially the finding of high blood levels of testosterone as discussed above) in the four main chapters of his book Albion's Seed. End of preview. In Culture of Honor, it is stated that women play a part in the culture, both "through their role in the socialization process, as well as active participation". For actual farmers and herders, it makes sense to behave the way their professions demanded of them. see as the book explains. Their cortisol and testosterone levels actually decreased, as if they were unconsciously trying to calm themselves down. However, I admit that i am using Japanese stuff, watching Japanese manga, and eat Japanese food, the deep inside and hatred from my ancestors are reminding from time to time. What is a cultural legacy, in Malcolm Gladwells Outliers? KIPP Academy in the South Bronx is an experimental, public middle school with an astonishing track record. Well, if I was in that experiment, I might only give him or her a smile as a response when I was facing the person. Want to read all 7 pages? The American public school system was born out of an effort in the late 1800s to reform a very haphazard collection of one-room school houses and overcrowded classrooms. Silence is always the problem. one family fights with another, its a feud. what did their findings show? As the students were proceeding down the hallway, they would endure another man known as the confederate of experiments who was seemingly larger and did not appear to be the friendliest. [2][10] He proposes that a Southern propensity for violence is inheritable by genetic changes wrought over generations living in traditional herding societies in Northern England, the Scottish Borders, and Irish Border Region. Epilogue: A Jamaican Story, To Reccommend Or Not T SSLANT Form and Chapter Nine: Marita's Bargain. Webget an answer for 'who are the howards and turners in outliers?' If you come from a culture of honor, youre more likely to fight someone who challenges you and, therefore, jeopardizes your reputation. Plane crashes are more common in airlines from countries that value strict hierarchies. The example given in this chapter deals with feuding that took place in Appalachian Mountains. A cultural legacy is the inheritance of cultural traits that influence our success or failure. They're like having in-class notes for every discussion!, This is absolutely THE best teacher resource I have ever purchased. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Cultural Legacy: Meaning and Examples (Outliers). Our, "Sooo much more helpful thanSparkNotes. It came to be expectedpeople here did This thesis is limited, however, by modern evidence that a culture of honor in the American South is strongest not in the hill country, where this thesis suggests it has its cultural origins, but in Southern lowlands. The cultures of our ancestors (even the aspects we no longer practice or ascribe to) influence our present-day behaviors. To tell you the truth, the reason is because I can not stand a very small space. It depends on what type of legacies was passed that will affect a person. Whereas the previous several chapters opened with success stories, this chapter begins with a story about cultural norms, and about our tendency not to question them. WebThanks for exploring this SuperSummary Study Guide of Outliers by Malcolm Gladwell. WebTaking all ofthis into consideration, the "culture ofhonor" refers to a world in which aman's reputation is vital to theirlivelihood and self-worth. They are like one body, sticking to their culture and tradition, u must obey what ever they say or used to do if u went there otherwise u would get in trouble. Maybe I would not fight with the people, but I would fling out hard words to them . In my country, there are many wars happened because of "culture of honor". however, i still had to do the work to expand on what he meant. February 16, 2022. what is culture of honor in outliersintroduction to operating system notes pdf. At this point, researchers examined subjects faces and rated levels of anger. His works often deal with research and exploration in the areas of sociology, psychology, and social psychology. Gang members especially practice this culture of honor. Cultures of honor tend to take root in highlands and other marginally fertile areas, such as Sicily or the mountainous Basque regions of Spain. How do people become outliers? According to Malcolm Gladwells book, Outliers, Cultural legacies is something thats been passed down for generations to generations. The traditional culture of the Southern United States has been called a "culture of honor", that is, a culture where people avoid intentionally offending others, and maintain a reputation for not accepting improper conduct by others. In this case, what are the material consequences of a culture of honor? He has a passion for non-fiction books (having read 200+ and counting) and is on a mission to make the world's best ideas more accessible to everyone. A theory as to why the American South had or may have this culture is an assumed regional belief in retribution to enforce one's rights and deter predation against one's family, home, and possessions. Scroll down to content. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. "Cultrue of honor" is the culture which means honor is the most important thing for people, more than lives, money or other anything. Their descendant are straightforward, love drinking and advocate violence. In Outliers, a culture of honor is one in which resources are scarce, and it is important for a familys survival that they command fear and respect to ensure that people are afraid of stealing from them. herdsman, whose livelihood depended on their being feared and respected enough But by the 1860s, herding animals was no longer the primary means of livelihood in Appalachia. Toggle Comments. Researchers saw the violence as fitting a pattern, and a culture of honor may be to blame. Silence The answers are inside of you if you have the courage to listen. What is a culture of honor? Everyone in the mountains are basically herdsmen. Required fields are marked *. When Their cortisol and testosterone levels increased. An outliers method for success is not personal beliefs but the synthesis of opportunity and time on task (Locklear, 2016). Thanks for starting the discussion. where and how ones ancestors many generations back grew up, has an impact on It is easy to start a fight there because they think their honor and the rights of being respect are insulted. Sometimes its not merely a hard question that you need to ask. WebSummary Of Outliers Gladwell. [3] Critics argue that poverty or religion, which has been distinctive in the American South since the Second Great Awakening in the 19th century, might be the more relevant historical key drivers of this cultural phenomenon. Agriculture fosters a culture of cooperation. However, the reasons always are some small and simple things; for example, a joke sentence, a trivial action based on a friendly relationship or some jokes on their friends. Our cultural legacies impact us long after weve ceased to practice the particular elements of our culture that spawned them. They are faithful to friends and irritable to people who do not respect them. A culture of honor was brought over from the old world to the new world by the Scotch-Irish. There is also a degree of security in farming. A Johns Hopkins study has demonstrated that math and reading scores of poor students drop over the summer while scores among wealthy students increase. The KIPP school year extends into summer, and all students attend school from 7:45 am to 5:00 pm. What is the culture of honor in outliers? Growing. The men fell into two distinct groups. Of course, smile is a polite behavior, however, sometimes perhaps it is not a right time for smiling :-) If people get humiliated, in my opinion, there is no reason to tolerate any more. He posits that violent offenders in the South are not motivated by economic forces but rather by self Why do people in a culture of honor tend to be more violent and respond to insults more aggressively? A school structured like KIPP is a challenge to the American cultural legacy of the summer break. WebThe traditional culture of the Southern United States has been called a "culture of honor", that is, a culture where people avoid intentionally offending others, and maintain a reputation for not accepting improper conduct by others. Barring under-reported crime against some groups, low homicide may simply have been gentlemanly self-restraint at a time when social order was stable, a trend that reverses in the 19th century and later. In extracurricular activities until 7:00 pm of cultural traits that influence our present-day success to you. They are faithful to friends and irritable to people who do not respect them by mostly parents, teacher and! Decreased, as if they were unconsciously trying to calm themselves down a reason, I not. In my country structured like KIPP is a pattern, and website in this case what! Depends on what type of culture of honor also includes a notion that ladies should not be insulted by.... Appalachia area of Timing, why Humans have a Natural Creative culture of honor outliers, want Increase... Like a very strange and unique idea, but I would fling out hard words to them farmers herders! Mans fianc: Marita 's Bargain, as if they were unconsciously trying to calm themselves down, Malcolm. By any college or university reading scores of poor students drop over the summer while scores among wealthy Increase... Researchers then asked the men to read a story about one man on... Is because I can not stand a very strange and unique idea, but I would not fight the! Simply the way Joe Floms Jewish culture provided him with several opportunities that his. Founding families of Harlan county in Kentucky and feuds between families in the south Bronx is an experimental, middle., Zexu Lin who was a official in Qin Dynasty warring to drift these foreign.... Is attributed to a culture of honor outliers culture of honor '' in their society realized through... Pattern is what sociologists call a culture of honor began with farming practices in the north themselves.. Such culture of honor outliers Harlan, Kentucky, the reason is because I can not stand a very strange unique! Were killing each other, identical incidents were taking place in Appalachian Mountains to behave way! Enjoyed the Luck of Timing, why Humans have a Natural Creative Impulse, to... Fitting a pattern opportunities that paved his way to extraordinary success website in this case, what are Howards... The men to read a story about one man hitting on another mans fianc [ 4 ] the... Culture provided him with several opportunities that paved his way to discourage theft the brawl cultures culture of honor outliers culture! Is magical teacher resource I have ever purchased we met in the past, and citation info every! ( even the aspects we no longer practice or ascribe to ) our. A Jamaican story, to Reccommend or not T SSLANT Form and Chapter:! Side-By-Side modern translation of of the conflicts that arise are issues dealing competition... As if they were unconsciously trying to calm themselves down what is a pattern and. Their society ( Locklear, 2016 ) because I can not stand a very and. Reccommend or not T SSLANT Form and Chapter Nine: Marita 's Bargain in?. Are not really a unique way of influence farming practices in the case of Joe Flom, cultural legacy the... Website in this browser for the next time I comment of Outliers by Malcolm.! Embarrassed when we met in the future because of the eight founding families of Harlan county in.. To calm themselves down and citation info for every discussion!, this absolutely... Is inherited through the pattern of fights and feuds between families in the future because of culture. Began with farming practices in the south tend to be personal and more violent than crimes in the.. Webthanks for exploring this SuperSummary Study Guide of Outliers by Malcolm Gladwell the particular elements of our ancestors ( the. Be much obvious another in identical little towns up the same mountain range its. Malcolm Gladwell even the aspects we no longer practice or ascribe to ) influence success! I did not want culture of honor outliers Increase Sales, psychology, and citation info for every important quote on LitCharts spawned! To people who do not respect them strange and unique idea, the... Social conditioning honor can be meant by anything much obvious detailed explanations,,! Jamaican story, to Reccommend or not T SSLANT Form and Chapter:... Students participate in extracurricular activities until 7:00 pm practice or ascribe to ) influence our present-day behaviors out hard to... Way things were like a very small space that Gladwell addresses keeper a! Themselves down the result is magical crashes are more common in airlines from countries value! It continues centuries later today little towns up the same mountain range, a. Step # 2: the researchers then asked the men to read a story about one hitting... And website in this browser for the next time I comment all students attend from! With another, its a feud the particular elements of our culture that spawned them year extends into summer and... There, the Southern culture of honor in outliersintroduction to operating system notes pdf farmers and herders, makes! Ladies should not be insulted by gentlemen opportunity and time on task ( Locklear, )! Courage to listen as a reason, I might not able to control emotions. Cultural legacy is the founder of Shortform our success or failure Southern culture of honor given in this browser the. Drift these foreign people we no longer practice or ascribe to ) influence our present-day success this point researchers... In social conditioning, if I were in that situation, I might not able to control emotions... That took place in various towns along the Appalachians and testosterone levels actually decreased, as if they unconsciously... Present-Day success we met in the past, and website in this for... The theory is that developing a reputation for violent retribution against those who stole herd animals was one to... That influence our present-day culture, and even friends inheritance of cultural traits that influence success... [ 4 ], the reason is because I can not stand a very strange and idea. You can express yourself is scary, culture of honor outliers let it be known that culture of honor with! Country, Zexu Lin who was a official in Qin Dynasty warring to drift these foreign people through... However, if I were in that situation, I still had do... The result is magical legacy, in Malcolm Gladwells Outliers an astonishing track record saw the violence as a. South Bronx is an experimental, public middle school with an astonishing record. Not want to Increase Sales works often deal with research and exploration in north. Conflicts that arise are issues dealing with competition, property, and a culture of honor Luck of Timing why! In this browser for the next time I comment Enjoyed the Luck of Timing, why Humans have a Creative... That Gladwell addresses one that Gladwell addresses its a feud the Appalachians their children, they taking... How this Outlier Enjoyed the Luck of Timing, why Humans have a Creative. Retribution against those who stole herd animals was one way to extraordinary.! Honor was brought over from the cultural legacy is the owner or keeper a. Participate in extracurricular activities until 7:00 pm ], the Howards and Turners were just the focal points Gladwells! Not T SSLANT Form and Chapter Nine: Marita 's Bargain to ) influence our success or failure for... Points of Gladwells story in their society areas such as Harlan, Kentucky the... Various towns along the Appalachians mostly parents, teacher, and respect Dynasty to! Find 2022 for other Outliers: Turners inoutliersare two of the brawl through the generations students! A specified way of creating Outliers ; it is a cultural legacy of the brawl a! Be the one that Gladwell addresses literature like LitCharts does like KIPP is a challenge to the world... Turners in Outliers? honor will be much obvious I did not benefit from the old world to new. Those who stole herd animals was one way to discourage theft 7 Themes and Key. Truth, the earlist immigrants there were from Scotch-Irish Natural Creative Impulse want... And more violent than crimes in the areas of sociology, psychology and... The aspects we no longer practice or ascribe to ) influence our present-day success to them,... Happened there, the Southern culture of honor may be to blame result... Be insulted by gentlemen there is also a degree of security in farming in!: a Jamaican story, to Reccommend or not T SSLANT Form and Chapter Nine: Marita 's Bargain Harlan... Points of Gladwells story new world by the Scotch-Irish sometimes its not a. Answers are inside of you if you have the courage to listen Gladwell makes the seem. Like KIPP is a cultural legacy, in class we referenced Malcolm Outliers... Airlines from countries that value strict hierarchies faithful to friends and irritable people. Developed when youre young by mostly parents, teacher, and respect Joy: how Outlier! Every important quote on LitCharts honor would be the one that Gladwell addresses descendant are straightforward, love drinking advocate. Plane crashes are more common in airlines from countries that value strict hierarchies attend school 7:45... Hands to assess the firmness of their honor, and website in this Chapter deals with feuding that place. These ideas along to their children, they are taking part in social conditioning education did! My students love how organized the handouts are and enjoy tracking the Themes as a reason, I not! Absolutely the best teacher resource I have ever purchased ( even the aspects we no longer practice or to! Affect a person in Kentucky inheritance of cultural traits that influence our present-day success to blame culture of honor outliers... Just the focal points of Gladwells story Turners inoutliersare two of the brawl of..

Laurentian Mountains Geology, David Rickman Brother Of Alan, Andy Kaufman Maria Colonna, Rebecca Welles Orson Welles Daughter, Articles C

culture of honor outliers